The Dead had shared the bill with Bob Dylan for a couple shows in 1986. But in anticipation of the slightly longer ’87 Dylan and the Dead tour, in which they planned to play together each night, the group gathered at Club Front to practice. They ended up working through well over 50 songs. And in Dead circles, the recordings have become more legendary than the July tour dates and with good reason.
For his part, Dylan, thought the rehearsals “would be as easy as jumping rope.” But, as he describes in Chronicles, “after an hour or so, it became clear to me that the band wanted to rehearse more and different songs than I had been used to doing…They wanted to run over all the songs, the ones they liked, the seldom seen ones. I found myself in a peculiar position and I could hear the brakes screech.”
This was, as we have described elsewhere, a – really the – low ebb in Dylan’s career. As he says about the Dead’s choices, “I had no feelings for any of those songs and didn’t know how I could sing them with any intent.” And this lack of confidence, imagination, and connection had permeated not only his rehearsal with the Dead or the music he had been playing recently on tour with Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers, but his entire being.
As he relates in Chronicles, “I felt like a goon and didn’t want to stick around.” So, he told the band that he forgot something back at his hotel and left Front Street with no intention of returning. But after walking a few blocks, he “heard the sounds of a jazz combo playing up ahead.” He stopped in the bar, ordered a gin and tonic, and watched the band play jazz ballads.
The singer “wasn’t very forceful, but he didn’t have to be; he was relaxed, but he sang with natural power.” And then Dylan had something like an epiphany. “Suddenly and without warning, it was like the guy had an open window to my soul. It was like he was saying, ‘You should do it this way.’” Dylan remembered a manner of singing that had once been automatic to him, “so elemental, so simple,” but that he had somehow forgotten.
He went back to Club Front. And suddenly the songs the Dead had been throwing at him no longer seemed like a burden. “Now I knew I could perform any of these songs without them having to be restricted to the world of words,” he remembered. “Maybe they just dropped something in my drink, I can’t say, but anything they wanted to do was fine with me.”
It is a great story. Maybe it even happened exactly that way. But Dylan’s other recollections of this period suggest that the revelation in that bar was only part of something larger happening at Front Street. The Dead, and Jerry in particular, were pushing Dylan toward precisely the thing he suddenly recognized in that anonymous singer: a way of inhabiting songs rather than merely reproducing them.
Years later, Dylan remembered Garcia prodding him along: “Come on man, you know, this is the way it goes, let’s play it, it goes like this.” Dylan’s reaction is revealing, “Man, he’s right, you know? How’s he gettin’ there and I can’t get there?” He later said that playing with the Dead made him realize that “they understood these songs better than I did at the time.”
That may be the real story buried inside Dylan’s wonderful little tale about walking out of rehearsal for a gin and tonic. The Dead were rummaging around in Dylan’s own songbook and finding possibilities that he could no longer see. They wanted the old songs, the obscure songs, the songs he thought he had left behind. And Garcia, especially, approached them not as artifacts with a correct arrangement or a particular meaning fixed decades earlier, but simply as songs that could still be played.
Dylan eventually described the lesson even more simply: “You’re either a player, or you’re not a player.” By 1987, he had spent years drifting in and out of touring, changing bands and increasingly losing his connection to his own material. The Dead were the opposite. They played. Night after night, year after year, pulling songs apart and putting them back together.
And you can hear Dylan beginning to get it on the Front Street tapes. The early rehearsals can be tentative and halting. But then something clicks. By “Man of Peace,” Garcia is slipping those gorgeous little phrases into the spaces Dylan leaves him, Dylan is responding, and what had begun as a rehearsal starts sounding like a band.
The stadium shows that followed never quite captured that magic. But maybe that is beside the point. Something happened in the rehearsals at Club Front. Dylan came in unable to imagine what he could possibly do with a pile of his own old songs. He came out remembering that he could still play them.
Whatever occurred, we get to enjoy the fruits. The harmonies on I’ll Be Your Baby Tonight with Jerry on pedal steel, the rich and full Queen Jane, Dylan’s vocals on the smoking Joey, Jerry giving us a dark and moody Senor, and so much more.


Leave a Reply